(Post)Photography as Affective Space
At the end of a summer marked by the visible resurgence of photography at major international events, such as the Venice Biennale, the exhibition “Living Spaces”, curated by Călina Coman, offered a rich synthesis of the concepts of space and life, based on a selection of photo-video projects that brought the local scene face-to-face with the global one, pushing photography toward the limits into a post-photographic register, recovering three-dimensionality and scenographic force. Structured in two phases, as part o “Living Spaces I” the project brought together at Galeria 2/3, in Bucharest, works by Bogdan Gîrbovan, Andrei Mateescu, Sebastian Stumpf, Katrin Streicher, Bill Ellis, Verónica Puche, Irina Rozovsky, Justine Kurland, Claudia Retegan, and Cristina Garabețanu. “Living Spaces II” expanded this exploration to the Constanța Art Museum, featuring works by Alexandru Paul, Andrei Șerban, Bill Ellis, Claudia Retegan, Ioana Dumitrescu & Alexandra Croitoru, Irina Rozovsky, Jordi Bernadó, Mihai Șovăială, Pixy Liao, Andrei Venghiac, Mircea Modreanu, Denise Lobonț, Ana Dumitru, Gabriela Mateescu, and Cristina Garabețanu & Mihai Zgondoiu.
A first encouraging observation is that the project launched by Galeria 2/3 reveals an unprecedented vibrancy of the photo -video scene in Bucharest, which no longer relies solely on one-off initiatives or hard-to-reach venues, but is increasingly establishing a strong hub right in the heart of the city, where at least three very active spaces dedicated to photography, moving images, and multimedia practices are already operating: Galeria 2/3, CAV – Multimedia, and Salonul de proiecte. A second observation concerns the thematic compatibility of local projects with the international scene and with topics that have been extensively explored in recent years, such as the phenomenology of dwelling, the affective quality of spaces, and the understanding of the environment not as an inert backdrop, but as a living network of relationships, reciprocities, and processes of coexistence. This perspective is supported by the curatorial text, which draws on Henri Lefebvre and, not least, Andreas Weber, the originator of concepts such as Erotic Ecology and Enlivenment, through which he proposes a reconsideration of the living world from the perspective of relationality, participation, and lived experience.
Thus, from a phenomenological perspective, space is no longer a neutral, homogeneous, and measurable container external to the subject, as it appeared in the modern geometric and scientific model, but rather emerges as lived space, oriented through the body and constituted by positioning, movement, proximity, distance, accessibility, and affect. These intuitions find their most compelling expression in art, where they radiate powerfully and directly, beyond any discursive framework. Worth mentioning here are a few powerful images from “Living Spaces,” where space is measured less in meters than in perceptual and affective intensities—in color, light, rhythm, and the density of the relationships it makes possible, such as Night Time Tremors by Katrin Streicher, in which three characters shrouded in twilight stare intently, appearing on the verge of suffocating inside a car, above which a white cloud of pollution hovers; Cathy by Andrei Șerban, where the female character evokes an Alice in Wonderland who has drunk the magic potion and grown so large that the everyday pantry, crowded with shelves and pots, can no longer contain her; and, last but not least, the sterile hospital setting in Andrei Mateescu’s gray (Gy) series. In the latter, the door to the radiotherapy room itself becomes the protagonist—a door whose handle you both want and don’t want to touch, a door in front of which painful hours of waiting accumulate and behind which an endless tunnel of fear opens up, punctuated by glimmers of hope, an inner landscape undulating endlessly between life-and-death diagnoses.
This reveals the central idea of dwelling: to dwell is intimately connected to being, through the indestructible bond between identity and the spaces in which we live, between ourselves and our landscapes or interiors. The idea of a phenomenological way of living—whose existential dimensions cannot be reduced to the mere possession of an address on an ID card—as well as the way in which we are imprinted by and imprint space, shines through with complete clarity in the 10/1 series, in which Bogdan Gîrbovan photographs ten studio apartments in a socialist-era apartment building constructed according to the principle of uniformity, where life triumphs and colors the space, shaping it according to each tenant, whose physical presence constitutes a primary punctum of the works. Even if identical according to the architectural plan, interiors are reshaped around favorite items, which constitute distinct affective centers: an imposing four-poster bed, a huge reddish Persian rug, a bookshelf crammed with books, the television or computer, plants, and pets. Architectural standardization is thus continually undermined by the uniqueness of each home, by the way in which each individual reorganizes, personalizes, and affectively invests in the same built volume.
Projects such as 10/1 and gray (Gy) also confirm the phenomenological intuition that one’s own body is not merely an object among other objects, but the center of one’s relationship with the world—the condition through which space acquires direction and meaning: near and far, up and down, inside and outside, familiar and foreign. Space thus becomes inseparable from experience, memory, perception, and corporeality, and dwelling does not merely denote the occupation of a material extension, but rather the concrete way in which the world organizes itself around a situated body. The gray (Gy) series radicalizes this relationship between the body and space, shifting it toward the invisible interior of the body itself. In this vein, Andrei Mateescu presents diptychs featuring patients photographed in front of the door to the radiation room, before and after their bodies have been exposed to radiation and their tissues have absorbed “an invisible surplus.” Although they dominate the composition, these bodies remain mysterious, resisting any attempt to visually grasp the transformations they undergo or the healing process itself, revealing themselves as invisible interior spaces, beyond the trivial meaning of a shell or a sum of organs.
A striking corporeal dimension also emerges in other images, such as Claudia Retegan’s work in which the human body hides among stones and yet exposes itself, covered by a shimmering thermal foil, in an attempt to experience an uncanny form of motionless dwelling; or in Mihai Șovăială’s work, where a photograph of a hoodie hanging on a wire fence—printed directly onto metal—embodies the anonymous labor that keeps every construction site alive; or in Ioana Dumitrescu’s self-portrait, in which the artist, dressed in white and with two white pillows tied around her waist, blends into the background. The same strategy of highlighting and, at the same time, concealing the body by chromatically neutralizing it within a white space reappears in Gabriela Mateescu’s video work Feed Me and in In One Dress by Pixy Liao.
In the very curatorial framework of the project, dwelling is explored in its physical, emotional, and social dimensions, and the body emerges as a “measuring instrument, receptor, and transitional agent,” always conditioned by the structures of the environment it traverses. This perspective is further explored throughout the exhibition: from Andrei Venghiac’s psychogeography and traces of construction sites documented by Mihai Șovăială to Bill Ellis’s experience of transit and an unstable “home,” the affective geographies of Irina Rozovsky and Verónica Puche, the negotiations of identity in the works of Claudia Retegan and Cristina Garabețanu, Jordi Bernadó’s architectural perspective, and the internal construction of the image in the work of Alexandru Paul. Denise Lobonț’s exploration of intimate-bodily dimension, alongside the forms of domestic habitation articulated by Ioana Dumitrescu, Cristina Garabețanu & Mihai Zgondoiu, complement a field in which space ceases to be mere framework and becomes a lived environment, permeated by memory, belonging, mobility, and distinct forms of presence.
We also note that 10/1 and gray (Gy), already iconic series that I myself included in the early 2000s in curatorial projects dedicated to dwelling, also fall within a post-photographic framework. Through their quasi-cinematic seriality, the two series subvert the classic reduction of photography to a single moment in time, reclaiming processuality, corporeality, and spatiality. The post-photographic dimension is further reinforced by the exhibition’s overall scenography: by the space’s design in the case of Galeria 2/3 which features geometric shapes arranged in a pattern; by the curtains punctuating the exhibition in Constanța lending it a spectacular dimension, and likewise by the presence of objects and installations created by Mircea Modreanu and Ana Dumitru.
Andreas Weber’s concept of enlivenment expands this perspective toward a relational understanding of life: organisms and environments are not separate entities, but transform one another through sensitivity, exchange, and participation. Such logic becomes apparent in Islands by Sebastian Stumpf, a video project that borders on contemplative cinema, where the body allows itself to be absorbed by the slow rhythms of the landscape and the almost hypnotic succession of frames, transcending mere representation and entering a realm of immersion, co-presence, and sensory experience of the environment as a space to be breathed in and lived within. The same logic reappears in the oscillation between the body’s visibility and concealment in Claudia Retegan’s work, in the temporary communities depicted in Justine Kurland’s Girl Pictures, in Irina Rozovsky’s affective geographies, and in the performative activation of space in the work of Mircea Modreanu and Gabriela Mateescu.
“Living Spaces” thus brings into play not only representations of inhabited spaces, but also the very processes through which they come to life: the body measures and affects them, memory imbues them with meaning, relationships transform them, and photography itself transcends its temporal and two-dimensional limits to become an object, a duration, an installation, and an environment. In this dual movement, space becomes part of the body, and the body, in turn, modifies it and imbues it with meaning. It is precisely here that photography becomes an affective space: it is no longer limited to capturing a place, but participates in its constitution and experience.
– by Raluca Oancea
– translated by Andrei Mateescu



















