Photographic Poetics of Politics
2023 was a busy year for Bucharest based artist-run space Switch Lab, coordinating a double photography-oriented exhibition, managing the launch of new artist hub Atelierele Scânteia, opening a new gallery space, curating the young female photographers show “Look at You. Now.” and Marina Caneve’s “Are They Rocks or Clouds?” The exhibition dyptich was curated by Sam Steverlynck under the name “Poetics of Politics”, first at Harlan Levey Projects in Brussels (June 10 – July 15, 2023) and later at Art Encounters ISHO House (September 21 – October 28, 2023) within the framework of Timișoara 2023 – European Capital of Culture. Probably in the hopes of more favorable positioning, the show in Brussels had as its subtitle “Bucharest School of Photography” in spite of featuring works by just three artists – Michele Bressan, Dani Ghercă, Nicu Ilfoveanu, turning a few heads in the process and raising some comments. Although it lacked one completely, irony has it such a subtitle would have been a better fit for the latter show in Timișoara. It offered a more diverse and ample perspective on photographers formed in Bucharest seeing how Alexandra Croitoru was also invited as an artist, who in turn invited and collaborated with young female artists recently graduated from the Bucharest photo-video department (where she teaches): Ana Conțu, Ioana Dumitrescu, Sonia Lupşa, Crăița Niga, Cătălina Pintilie, Roberta Roată. Nevertheless, with the exhibitions being distinct rather than simply itinerated, Steverlynck successfully managed to illustrate much of the themes, approaches and aesthetics surrounding what could be deemed a Bucharest School of Photography. The Timișoara exhibition was concerned with overlapping traces of the past in present contexts, exposing difficulties needing to be overcome for the future, while the Brussels one was loosely focused on the difficult transition period (for Romania and much of the former Eastern Bloc) between communism and a democracy accompanied by liberal market policies.
Larisa Sitar was likewise present in the Harlan Levey Projects exhibition, although incidentally, collaborating with Michele Bressan on the Generation Loss (2019) video – an extended still shot of the notorious People’s House, the second biggest administrative building in the world. It was a megalomaniacal project of dictator Nicolae Ceaușescu (1918-1989) which required the leveling of roughly 40.000 houses in Bucharest’s historic districts. The imprint it left, however, is not just architectural, as the trauma still collectively lingers between the city’s inhabitants to this day. Bressan and Sitar filmed the work twenty years after the revolution and copied the material on a VCR overriding it twenty times (again) until the image was glitched out, barely recognizable. The work thus eloquently illustrates difficulties Romania has in processing its own history, often enveloped in vagueness, overriding narratives and brutality.
One of the numerous side effects the transition period invited was the disappearance of most cinema halls spread throughout the country. Some were run-down, some destroyed, but the majority were simply repurposed into more profitable or easy to maintain businesses, leaving few other options for viewers other than mall multiplexes. In his “Waiting for the Drama” (2010) series, Michele Bressan photographed many of the only 29 state cinemas left at the time. He opted to point his camera not towards the screen, but towards the rows of empty seats, waiting indefinitely to be filled. The implication encouraged by the title lets timeframes overlap, as the images give hints of halls aesthetically stuck in the past (1970s and 1980s) waiting for an implausible future. Bressan accurately identifies another symbol of transition with his “RABLA” series (2011 – 2013). In 2005 Romania launched an ambitious programme with the goal of modernizing the cars running on its streets. Owners of cars that were older than ten years could exchange their vehicle for a voucher in order to purchase a new one. A vast majority of these were Dacias built in the 1970s and 1980s, which at the time was the only available option for most of the populace. Bressan toured several REMAT centers, witnessing the transformation of Dacia cars, once a supposed source of national pride, into abstract heaps of scrap metal.
In the middle of the Harlan Levey space Dani Ghercă brought works from his ongoing “A Glimpse of Disconnection”, in the striking sculptural presence by now characteristic of the series – sporting Diasec prints encapsulated in thick rectangular panels. For the project he took aerial shots of various cities embodying the Metropolis (technology ridden urban agglomerations having millions of inhabitants), but takes care in underexposing the photograph so locations are unidentifiable. This technique, together with some minor post-processing, leaves scarce details beside the buildings’ hard edges, reflecting elements and rooftops. The resulting images are filled with abstract geometric patterns and, quite strikingly, more akin to circuit boards than urban landscapes, providing a chilling view on contemporary life, where humanity transforms in mere sources of (big) data. Ghercă likewise brought his House of the Free Press work from the “4 Houses” series (2015-2016). In it the artist displays his inclination for scrutinising relations between architecture, scale, and power by showcasing four imposing Soviet-era buildings which once stood as symbols of pride during the communist era. Ghercă’s deadpan photographs captured frontally unveil the still lingering dominance of the structures over their urban environment and institutional discourse.
Back in 2004 Nicu Ilfoveanu developed two pictures left on a film in an old box-camera gifted to him, thus revealing latent images which up until then were stuck in limbo for aproximately fifty years. This led him to the ”Steampunk Autochrome” (2004-2008) series, included in the Brussels exhibition. The title is a clear reference to the Steampunk aesthetic romanticizing the industrial revolution (and its ruins) and to the autochrome developing process that enabled the first color photographs. The project is one of the most recognizable and distinct endeavors in recent Romanian photography. While most of his contemporaries resorted to straight photography in simply documenting the country’s transition, Ilfoveanu did it by embracing archaic technology (and its limitations) to dramatic effect, capturing images from the present and letting the past seep in through the medium itself. The images exhibit a dreamlike haze and seemingly random color effects, applied not to nostalgic scenes, but rather across post-industrial landscapes, desolate wastelands, and austere housing blocks.
Fast forward a few months later, for the Timișoara exhibition Michele Bressan opted to approach ruins directly, using works from his ongoing “Geometries of Failure”. The two wall-mounted prints were made in the halls of the former AVERSA factory in Bucharest and, using striking pictorial imagery, revealed contrasts between a supposed gloomy past (decaying walls) and a supposed luminous future (bright windows). The situation is quite different in reality of course, seeing how the factory was shortly destroyed after Michele took the images. Near these prints, as if signaling the formal variety in which these artists express themselves, another work from “Geometries of Failure” could be found. Sculpturally placed on the floor, it featured the image of a geometrically damaged iron grill in a metal slanted box to very impressing effect (similar to Lucian Bran’s wood lightboxes from his 2021 “From Centuries Ago to Eons to Come”).
In the same room Nicu ilfoveanu had works from his “Mio Dio” (2023) series, where he photographed animals from museum dioramas and hallways. The images were taken while the institution was renovated, with the inert animals covered in thin plastics, only small parts of them visible or discernable (revealing what they actually are). Capturing them thusly turns the notion of freezing time on its head, as the illusions usually enforced by both museum and photo camera are deconstructed. I thoroughly enjoyed how one of these images was (visibly) hidden behind a white panel in a corner, forcing the viewer to investigate, giving the sense he’s glancing at something forbidden, backstage. Ilfoveanu’s “Found & Lost” (2011) was likewise present, albeit as digital projection instead of its original publication format. For it, Ilfoveanu studied a flea market for a year, more interested in perusing people with their recurring gestures and trading rituals than the past-infused objects they exchange. He also had a video on display – “DELTA3” (2013), where he captured the Danube Delta using eerie photographic still shots accompanied by metallic sounds and music scores from the Lipovan Choir, imbuing the work with nostalgia.
This form of attachment to the past, nostalgia, lays at the base of another video in the show – Michele Bressan’s “Bucharest-Herculane” (2010). Shot on Super 8 film, it shows fleeting human figures through the windows of a car, blasting Wagner music on its speakers. It functions as a testament to the passage of time and, with the help of its soundtrack, commemorates the old glory days of the “Herculean Baths” vacation resort.
Alexandra Croitoru’s “Ways to Protect Your Mind” (2023), created in collaboration with the six young female artists (mentioned above), aesthetically stood out compared with her colleagues. It dominated the white cube room it was installed in with deceptively simple black and white portraits hanging from the ceiling, forcing viewers to navigate through textile prints slightly exceeding actual scale. The photographs imitated attributes and body language characteristics of male dominated portrait history, but used everyday household objects as paraphernalia and armor to ludic effect, toying with the language of power. Reaching the end of the room, at least based on exhibition point of entry, one could see a makeshift whip out of tailor measure tapes stuck on the wall referencing her name (“Croitoru” translates to “tailor” in Romanian), rendering visible her position of authority, deconstructing it.
Just like its Brussels counterpart, the Art Encounters exhibition featured finely produced prints in impressive frames, carefully placed in aesthetically pleasing environments, with the added bonus of a couple of atmospheric videos in Timișoara. The two shows uncover much of the range of practices used by Bucharest-formed photographers, Steverlynck aptly identifying their penchant for social themes, critical approach, meta-usage of the medium or openness towards alternative methods of display. However, this was done at the cost of thematic cohesion and, at times, even at the cost of a visual one. I left ISHO House visually satisfied for example, satiated even, by the professionalism and high production values it implied. But I must admit I did so more confused than I would’ve hoped, having a rough time interpreting these loosely connected works as a whole, being clear how both exhibitions functioned more as showcases – seemingly putting on display the best of what each artist has to offer.
– by Andrei Mateescu
*
This journalistic material was produced with funding from ENERGIE! Creation Grants, awarded by the Municipality of Timișoara, through the Project Centre, within the national cultural program “Timișoara – European Capital of Culture in 2023”.
The material does not necessarily represent the position of the Timișoara City Project Centre and the Centre is not responsible for its content or how it may be used.
*